Medicare Supplement (Medigap) Plans

Online Medicare Supplement Premium Comparison Database

Medicare’s interactive website tool allows you to compare Medicare supplement plans quickly and easily. To begin, click the search button below and enter your zip code. You will be taken to another web page. Enter your age, gender and whether or not you use tobacco products and select “Update Prices”.

You may then select “Plan Details” to review the coverage for each standardized Medicare supplement plan, or “View Policies” to review the list of companies offering that plan along with their estimated premiums. This site has the most up-to-date information of plans available in North Carolina.

There are many factors that go in to determining rates for a policy, including age, gender, tobacco status, where you live, discounts, and medical underwriting if applicable. 
 

Find a Medigap policy that works for you

Medicare supplement plans, also referred to as Medigap plans, are one health insurance option for people with Original Medicare. Standardized Medicare supplement plans A- N are designed to fill the gaps left by Original Medicare (Parts A and B). These are sold by private insurance companies as individual insurance policies and are regulated by the Department of Insurance.

Tab/Accordion Items

The Medicare Supplement Open Enrollment Period is a one-time, six-month period that begins the first month a person is both 65 or older and enrolled in Medicare Part B. It does not repeat every year.

During the open enrollment period, beneficiaries are guaranteed the ability to buy any of these plans from any company that sells them.  Companies cannot deny coverage or charge more for current or past health problems. 

The insurance company may impose a pre-existing condition waiting period, but it cannot be longer than six months. This would include any health condition diagnosed or treated six months prior to the Medicare supplement application. If a person has prior creditable coverage.

If you do not apply for a Medicare supplement policy within your Open Enrollment Period, you may lose the right to a Medicare supplement policy without regard to your health. 

You can apply for a Medicare supplement policy outside of your Open Enrollment Period.  However, insurance companies can use medical underwriting to decide whether or not to accept your application. 

Medicare supplemental insurance federal regulations do not guarantee eligibility to individuals under age 65 who are eligible for Medicare due to disability.  However, North Carolina legislatively mandates eligibility to individuals eligible for Medicare due to disability.

North Carolina G.S. 58-54-45 guarantees that individuals under the age of 65 who qualify for Medicare are eligible to purchase a Medigap policy A, D, or G effective January 1, 2020. 

Premiums may be higher for Medicare disability beneficiaries than for Medicare beneficiaries 65 or older.

When a Medicare disabled beneficiary turns 65 years old, they will have a new six-month open enrollment period and be able to purchase any of the standardized Medicare supplement insurance.

You will not be auto enrolled into a Medicare supplement policy and must make application directly with the insurance company.  You will need to contact the insurance company that sells the specific policy that you wish to purchase, or you may contact an agent who sells the specific policy you want.  We recommend that you apply at least 30 days before you want the policy to start.  If you do not have thirty days, apply as soon as possible. 

Supplement premiums are paid directly to the insurance company and are not deducted from your Social Security payments.

  • Decide which plan you want. Compare the benefits each plan helps pay for and choose a plan that covers what you need.
  • Pick your policy.  Price is the only difference between policies with the same letter sold by different companies. 
  • Contact the company or a licensed insurance agent to get a quote.  Prices can change at any time based on when you buy, your health conditions, and more. 

MEDIGAP COMPANY NAMES SOLD IN NCPhone Number
AARP Medicare Supplement Plans, insured by United Healthcare1-888-378-0849
ACCENDO INSURANCE COMPANY (a CVS company and Aetna affiliate)1-800-358-8749
ACE MEDICARE SUPPLEMENT ( a Chubb Company)1-215-640-1000
AETNA HEALTH AND LIFE INSURANCE COMPANY1-800-358-8749
ALLSTATE INSURANCE COMPANY1-888-781-0585
AMERICAN BENEFIT LIFE INSURANCE COMPANY1-833-504-0331
AMERICAN FAMILY LIFE ASSURANCE COMPANY (AFLAC)1-866-990-2668
AMERICAN FINANCIAL SECURITY LIFE INSURANCE COMPANY1-866-951-0686
ASSURED LIFE ASSOCIATION1-877-223-3666
BANKERS FIDELITY LIFE INSURANCE COMPANY1-866-458-7504
BLUE CROSS AND BLUE SHIELD OF NORTH CAROLINA1-800-478-0583
CIGNA NATIONAL HEALTH INSURANCE COMPANY1-855-891-9368
ELIPS LIFE INSURANCE COMPANY1-877-969-5675
ERIE FAMILY LIFE INSURANCE COMPANY1-800-458-0811
FEDERAL LIFE INSURANCE COMPANY (MUTUAL)1-888-747-3760
GLOBE LIFE & ACCIDENT INSURANCE COMPANY1-888-678-3403
GPM HEALTH AND LIFE INSURANCE COMPANY1-866-242-7573
GUARANTEE TRUST LIFE INSURANCE COMPANY1-800-338-7452
HEARTLAND NATIONAL LIFE INSURANCE COMPANY1-866-916-7971
HUMANA INSURANCE COMPANY1-800-457-4708
HUMANA INSURANCE COMPANY (ACHIEVE)1-888-602-7443
LIBERTY BANKERS LIFE INSURANCE COMPANY1-844-770-2400
LIFE SHIELD1-800-851-5041
MANHATTAN LIFE ASSURANCE COMPANY1-800-877-7703
MEDICO INSURANCE COMPANY1-800-822-9993
Medmutual Protect1-800-654-9106
NASSAU LIFE INSURANCE COMPANY1-860-403-5000
NATIONAL HEALTH INS CO (ALLSTATE)1-866-576-2956
NEW ERA LIFE INSURANCE COMPANY1-877-417-7555
OLD SURETY LIFE INS CO1-800-272-5466
OMAHA INSURANCE COMPANY1-800-667-2937
PEKIN LIFE INSURANCE COMPANY1-800-322-0160
PHYSICIANS MUTUAL INSURANCE COMPANY1-800-325-6300
PROSPERITY LIFE GROUP1-800-848-5433
ROYAL ARCANUM1-833-585-0550
STATE FARM MUTUAL AUTOMOBILE INSURANCE COMPANY1-800-782-8332
THE AMERICAN HOME LIFE INSURANCE COMPANY1-800-876-0199
THE CAPITOL LIFE INSURANCE COMPANY1-844-770-2400
THE ORDER OF UNITED COMMERCIAL TRAVELERS OF AMERICA1-800-848-0123
TRANSAMERICA LIFE INSURANCE COMPANY1-866-205-9120
UNION SECURITY INSURANCE COMPANY1-833-552-0827
UNITED AMERICAN INSURANCE COMPANY1-800-331-2512
UNITED INSURANCE COMPANY OF AMERICA1-800-654-9106
UNITED STATES FIRE INSURANCE COMPANY (A CRUM & FORSTER COMPANY)1-973-490-6600
USAA LIFE INSURANCE COMPANY1-800-531-8722
WASHINGTON NATIONAL INSURANCE COMPANY1-800-621-3724
WELLCARE (Centene)1-866-527-0056
Woodmenlife1-402-449-7771
On This Page Jump Links
Off